Home / IB DP Biology C4.2 Transfers of energy and matter-FA 2025- IB Style Questions For SL Paper 2

IB DP Biology C4.2 Transfers of energy and matter-FA 2025- IB Style Questions For SL Paper 2

Question

The diagram shows a simplified marine food web in an area of the North Pacific Ocean.

(a) Identify the
(i) trophic level of sea lions.
(ii) type of interspecific relationship between orca whales and sea otters.

(b) Ex situ conservation measures are being introduced due to a rapid decline in sea otter populations. Describe the advantages of ex situ conservation.

(c) A pyramid of energy can be constructed to show energy flows in this food web. Outline one limitation of these pyramids.

▶️ Answer/Explanation

(a)

(i) The sea lion is a secondary consumer because it eats fish, which are primary or secondary consumers. It belongs to trophic level 3.

(ii) The relationship between orca whales and sea otters is a predator-prey relationship, as orcas hunt and feed on sea otters.

(b)

Ex situ conservation involves protecting a species outside its natural environment, such as in aquariums, zoos, or marine reserves. This method allows scientists to:

  • Monitor health and provide optimal conditions for survival.
  • Run captive breeding programs to increase population numbers.
  • Act as a backup if the species disappears in the wild.
  • Be useful when natural habitats are severely damaged or dangerous.

(c)

A limitation of pyramids of energy is that they don’t account for decomposers, which play a key role in recycling energy and nutrients. Also, species that feed at multiple levels can make it hard to assign accurate trophic positions.

Markscheme: 

(a)

  • (i) Secondary consumer / third trophic level / trophic level 3 / 3
  • (ii) Predation / predator-prey relationship

(b)

  • Protecting species outside their natural habitats in zoos/aquariums/botanical gardens
  • Essential requirements can be managed/monitored
  • Allows breeding programs
  • Useful when there is a serious decline/destruction of natural habitats OR when there is a threat to individuals in the wild

(c)

  • Do not show seasonal variations in energy transfers OR
  • Difficult to assign species to a specific trophic level OR
  • Do not show energy transfer to decomposers

Question

The mass of an individual organism can affect its physiology and feeding ecology. The diagram shows the relative mass of carbon (black) and total wet mass (grey) of a marine crustacean, Calanus hyperboreus and a jellyfish, Bathocyroe fosteri.

Carbon and wet mass comparison of crustacean and jellyfish

(a) State one process that results in the loss of carbon dioxide from a marine organism such as a crustacean or a jellyfish. 

(b) The crustacean and the jellyfish obtain carbon compounds by feeding. State one source of carbon for marine organisms, other than feeding. 

(c) Explain how energy enters, flows through and is lost from marine food chains. 

(d) (i) Deduce whether jellyfish or crustacea are a richer source of carbon in a food chain. 

(ii) Suggest with a reason whether having a large body mass is an advantage or disadvantage for jellyfish. 

▶️ Answer/Explanation

(a)

 Carbon dioxide is lost during aerobic respiration, where organic compounds are broken down to release energy.

(b)

Marine organisms can also obtain carbon through photosynthesis, particularly those containing symbiotic algae, or by absorbing dissolved carbon compounds like CO₂ or bicarbonate ions from seawater.

(c)

  • Energy enters marine ecosystems via sunlight, which is captured by photosynthetic organisms like phytoplankton.
  • This energy is then transferred through the food web as organisms consume other organisms.
  • However, only a small proportion (around 10%) of the energy is passed on to each next level.
  • A large part of the energy is lost as heat during metabolic processes like respiration, or as undigested matter.
  • Unlike nutrients, energy is not recycled in ecosystems and must be continuously supplied.

(d)(i)

Crustaceans contain more carbon relative to their body mass compared to jellyfish, so they are a richer source of carbon in food chains.

(d)(ii)

It can be a disadvantage, as large jellyfish have low carbon density and a lower surface area to volume ratio, which can limit gas and nutrient exchange. Additionally, their high water content offers little nutritional value to predators.

Alternatively, you could say it’s an advantage because a larger body size might help avoid predation or allow for greater reproduction, depending on context.

 

Markscheme: 

a.
• Aerobic/cellular respiration
• Gas exchange/diffusion
Note: Photosynthesis and breathing are not acceptable answers.

b.
• Photosynthesis
• Absorption of dissolved CO2/carbonate/hydrogencarbonate directly from seawater

c.
• Light energy is converted to chemical energy (in carbon compounds) via photosynthesis
• Chemical energy flows through food chains via feeding relationships
• Only ~10% of energy transfers between trophic levels
• Energy is lost as heat through respiration
• Energy is not recycled in ecosystems
• Some energy remains trapped in undigested detritus/fossil fuels

d.i.
Crustaceans are richer in carbon (more carbon per unit volume) compared to jellyfish which have little carbon relative to total body size.

d.ii.
Advantages:
• Can capture larger prey
• Lower predation rates
• Greater reproductive capacity

Disadvantages:
• Slower movement for predator avoidance/prey capture
• Higher metabolic demands
• Lower surface area:volume ratio affecting gas/nutrient exchange
• More vulnerable to mechanical damage
Note: Must clearly state whether advantage or disadvantage.

Question

Beavers are large rodents that live in waterways throughout the northern hemisphere. Dams made by beavers change the temperature of the streams and affect the mayfly, Baetis bicaudatus. In the summer of 2008, beaver ponds in West Brush Creek and Cement Creek, Colorado, were studied to evaluate their impacts on mayflies. The study sites included streams flowing into (upstream) and out of (downstream) each beaver pond.

Mayflies, including the species B. bicaudatus, are aquatic insects that hatch and spend their larval stages in water emerging from the water as adults. Larger females produce an increased number of better quality eggs.

The table shows the mean temperature differences (downstream – upstream) and mean dry mass for female and male mayflies.

The bat, Pipistrellus nathusii, feeds on insects including mayflies. A study was undertaken in Poland to see the effect of European beavers (Castor fiber) on the activity of bats. Beaver activity can affect forests that are covered by trees and meadows that are covered by grasses and have no trees. The following habitats were studied:

  • forest (F)
  • flooded forest with canopy gaps created by beavers and flooding due to the presence of beaver dams (FFG)
  • forest with canopy gaps created by beavers but no flooding (FG)
  • meadow (M)
  • meadow with flooding due to the presence of beaver dams (MF)

As bats feed they fly through the air catching insects. The number of feeding passes made by bats was counted. The graph shows differences in the bat activity between particular habitats.

a. Calculate the difference in the mean dry mass of mayflies upstream and downstream of Cement Creek pond 9 for female and male mayflies.

b. Describe the effect dams have on water temperature.

c. The graph shows the mean dry mass of mayflies relative to the water temperature in their habitats.

Using the graph, discuss evidence for the hypothesis that mayflies grow to greater dry mass in cooler water.

d. Analyse the data to find the effect of flooding and tree felling by beavers on the activity of bats. 
e. The trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss, that live in West Brush Creek and Cement Creek also feed on the mayflies. Fishermen come to Colorado to catch and eat trout. Draw a diagram of part of a food web for the creeks in Colorado, including mayflies, humans, trout and bats. 
f. Identify an example of competition between organisms in this food web. 
g. The North American beaver (Castor canadensis) was introduced to islands adjacent to Argentina and Chile where they have become an invasive species. Discuss one ecological criterion (a basis for deciding) whether beavers are harmful or helpful to the ecosystems there. 
▶️ Answer/Explanation

a. 

From the table:

  • Females (pond 9):
    Upstream = 2.05 mg, Downstream = 2.09 mg
    Difference = 2.09 − 2.05 = +0.04 mg

  • Males (pond 9):
    Upstream = 1.57 mg, Downstream = 1.45 mg
    Difference = 1.45 − 1.57 = −0.12 mg

b. 

  • The height of the dam appears to influence temperature differences.
  • High dams tend to cool the downstream water (negative temperature difference).
  • Low dams tend to warm the downstream water (positive temperature difference).
  • One example (pond 5) shows no temperature change (0.0 °C difference).

c. 

  • There is a general negative trend in the graph: as temperature increases, dry mass decreases, which supports the hypothesis.
  • However, the trend line is shallow and data points are widely scattered, particularly at higher temperatures.
  • An exception is that female mayflies in water >10°C have the highest dry mass, which contradicts the hypothesis in that range.
  • So, the graph partially supports the hypothesis but has notable exceptions.

d. Analyse the data to find the effect of flooding and tree felling by beavers on the activity of bats.

From the bar graph:

  • Bat activity (feeding passes) is lowest in forest (F) and meadow (M) habitats.
  • Tree felling alone (FG) slightly increases activity compared to forest.
  • Flooding alone (MF) also increases activity compared to meadow.
  • The highest activity is in flooded forest with canopy gaps (FFG) — where both flooding and tree felling occur.
  • Thus, both tree felling and flooding increase bat activity, but flooding has a greater effect overall, especially when combined with tree felling.

e.

f. 

Trout and bats compete for mayflies, as both consume them as a food source.

g. 

Criterion: Biodiversity

Harmful: If beaver activity reduces native species or causes habitat degradation, leading to a loss of biodiversity, they would be considered damaging.

Helpful: If beavers increase habitat complexity (e.g., creating ponds and wetlands), this might increase biodiversity by supporting more species — thus, they could be beneficial.

Other valid criteria might include impact on water quality, erosion, or alteration of food webs.

Markscheme: 

a.

I. female: «+» 0.04 «mg»
AND
II. male: «–» 0.12 «mg»
Both needed.

b.

a. height of dam affects the temperature
b. high dams tend to cool the water
c. low dams tend to warm the water
d. pond 5/one pond shows no change/stays the same

c.

a. trend lines support «the hypothesis»
OR
trend shows a negative correlation shown «between increased temperature and size»
Do not credit answers with just numbers.
Accept “line of best fit” wtte.

b. the trend line is shallow / small slope
OR
there is a large amount of scatter at higher temperatures (reducing the certainty)
OR
wide/overlapping ranges so no significant difference «(at» 9°C)

c. (hypothesis not supported because) females in water over 10°C have the highest «mean dry» mass
Words other than “hypothesis not supported” may be used: “as opposed to”, “whereas”, to express deviation from support.

d.

a. both flooding and tree felling increases bat passes/activity / WTTE
b. flooding has greater/increase on bat passes/activity / WTTE
OR
flooding has the greater impact than tree felling on bat passes
c. supporting argument from the data

e.

a. arrow pointing from trout to human
b. arrows pointing from mayflies to trout and bats
Award [1 max] if answer does NOT show all 4 organisms.

f.

bats and trout compete for mayflies

g.

a. criterion
b. reason that beavers damage
c. reason that beavers help

eg,
a. biodiversity
b. if indigenous species are eliminated biodiversity is reduced, then the beavers would be seen as damaging
c. if biodiversity increases (due to the engineering of waterways), then beavers could be a benefit

Consider criteria something that may be dealt with from a range of perspectives.
Other possible criteria: abiotic disturbance changes to food webs diversity

Question

The continued survival of all living organisms depends on sustainable communities in which plants play a vital role.

a. Outline how energy flows in an ecosystem. 

b. Describe how plants affect the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. 

c. Explain how a newly discovered plant species would be classified and named. 

▶️ Answer/Explanation

a. Energy flow in an ecosystem

  1. Energy enters the ecosystem from sunlight.
  2. Producers (mainly green plants) capture light energy through photosynthesis.
  3. The light energy is converted into chemical energy in the form of organic compounds.
  4. Consumers obtain energy by eating plants or other animals.
  5. At each trophic level, most energy is lost as heat during respiration.
  6. Only about 10% of the energy is transferred to the next trophic level.
  7. Decomposers use energy from dead organisms and waste products.
  8. Energy flows in one direction and cannot be recycled in the ecosystem.

b. Role of plants in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels

  1. Plants absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere during photosynthesis.
  2. They convert carbon dioxide into glucose and other organic compounds.
  3. Plants release carbon dioxide back into the atmosphere through respiration.
  4. When plants die and decompose, some carbon is returned as carbon dioxide.
  5. If decomposition is incomplete, carbon can be stored in peat or fossil fuels.
  6. Burning plant material or fossil fuels releases stored carbon as carbon dioxide.

c. Classification and naming of a newly discovered plant species

Naming:

  1. The plant is given a binomial name (genus + species), e.g., Rosa canina.
  2. The genus name starts with a capital letter; the species name is lowercase.
  3. This naming system is standardized and used globally.

Classification:

  • Scientists study the plant’s features: structure, reproductive organs, and genetic material.
  • The plant is grouped with similar species based on shared characteristics.
  • Modern classification often uses DNA or protein sequence comparisons.
  • Plants are organized into clades—groups that share a common ancestor.
  • Cladograms are diagrams that show evolutionary relationships between species.
  •  Classification is now based more on evolutionary history than on just physical traits.

Markscheme: 

Answer to part (a): Energy flow in ecosystems

a. Energy from the sun is captured by plants/autotrophs

b. Light energy is converted to chemical energy by photosynthesis

c. Energy is passed to animals/consumers/along the food chain

d. At each stage in the food chain energy is lost by respiration/as heat

e. Much less energy/only about \(10\%\) is available at each stage/trophic level of the food chain

f. Some energy is made available to decomposers when organisms die/parts fall to the ground

g. Energy cannot be recycled

Answer to part (b): Plants and carbon dioxide

a. Plants reduce the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere by photosynthesis

b. Carbon dioxide is fixed/converted into organic substances/sugars (OWTTE)

c. Plants respire which releases carbon dioxide into the atmosphere

d. Plant decomposition may release \(\mathrm{CO}_2\)

e. Carbon in dead plants is trapped/stored in fossil fuels/peat

f. Combustion of plants/wood/fossil fuels adds to the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere

Answer to part (c): Plant classification and naming

Naming:

a. Binomial nomenclature / (plant is) given a binomial/double name

b. First name is the genus and second name is the species / genus initial upper case and species lower case

c. Names (of plant species) are international/are universally understood/are published in journals

Classification:

d. Study the characteristics/structure/reproduction/chemical properties/DNA (of the plant)

e. Put/classify (the plant) in a group/genus with other similar species

f. Natural classification corresponds with evolution / natural classification is based on many features

g. Analogous features/features due to convergent evolution should not be used

h. Hierarchy of groups/taxa (in traditional classification) / 3 or more taxa in correct sequence (kingdom-phylum-class)

i. Two or more of bryophyta, filicinophyta, coniferophyta and angiospermophyta named

j. A clade is a group of organisms evolved from a common ancestor

k. Base sequences/amino acid sequences used to group organisms into clades/deduce evolutionary relationships

l. Cladograms show the relationships between clades/likely evolutionary divergence of clades

m. Each branch point/node represents where species are formed via divergent evolution

n. Species are now classified into a sequence of clades (rather than a rigid hierarchy of taxa)

Scroll to Top